Johnny Marr Opposes the Use of a Smiths Song by Donald Trump

In January 2024, Johnny Marr, former guitarist of the iconic band The Smiths, publicly condemned the use of the song “Please, Please, Please, Let Me Get What I Want” at Donald Trump’s political rallies. This stance, shared on social media, reflects the outrage shared by many artists over the unauthorized use of their work.

A Shocking Discovery for Johnny Marr

The issue came to light when political journalists on X posted videos showing the Smiths’ song played at Trump rallies in Rapid City, South Dakota, in September 2023, and in Laconia, New Hampshire, in January 2024. In response, Johnny Marr expressed his indignation on X, stating: “I never in a million years would’ve thought this could happen. Consider this shut down right now.”

This reaction underscores his firm opposition to the association of The Smiths’ music with the campaign of the former U.S. president, known for his controversial positions. Marr, who co-wrote the song with singer Morrissey in 1984, made it clear he did not approve of this use.

A Recurring Issue for Artists

Johnny Marr is not the first artist to object to Trump using their music. Musicians like The Rolling Stones, Neil Young, Rihanna, Aerosmith, and the estates of Tom Petty and Prince have also raised objections, sometimes issuing cease-and-desist letters. However, preventing such use is complex. Political campaigns can obtain blanket licenses from organizations like BMI or ASCAP, allowing them to play songs without direct artist consent.

Although Marr threatened action, he did not specify whether he would pursue legal measures. Some artists, like Neil Young, have filed lawsuits for copyright infringement, but with mixed results.

A Divide with Morrissey

This controversy also highlights the differences between Johnny Marr and Morrissey, the former lead singer of The Smiths. While Marr is known for his progressive views and rejection of conservative politicians, Morrissey has sparked controversy in recent years by supporting nationalist ideas, such as Brexit and the For Britain party. However, Morrissey himself has criticized Trump in the past, stating in 2017 that he would “kill him for the sake of humanity” before retracting the comment.

A Matter of Values and Legacy

For Johnny Marr, the use of The Smiths’ music in a political context he disapproves of is an affront to the band’s legacy. Formed in Manchester in 1982, The Smiths are an icon of 1980s alternative music, known for their introspective lyrics and unique sound. Marr, who shaped the band’s distinctive guitar melodies, seeks to protect this cultural identity.

This controversy underscores the tension between artistic control and the public use of music. While Marr has vowed to “shut it down,” the legal complexities make the outcome uncertain. This episode remains a striking example of artists’ struggles to preserve the integrity of their work against unwanted uses.